True North Agency · ASPCA · Digital donor acquisition

It was us. We let the dogs out.

ASPCA
92%
New-to-file donors in the first year
+12%
Monthly donors, year over year
+18%
Average gift vs. offline channels
Gold
ECHO Award, 2013
My role
Creative Director. Creative direction, art direction, strategy, video production
Agency
True North Agency
Client
ASPCA
Channels
Display, social, programmatic, and streaming video with Hulu, Amazon, Zynga, and eBay
01 — The problem

A TV-first charity with an aging donor base.

The ASPCA came to us having never run an online campaign (this was 2012). They were skeptical of the web as a fundraising tool and had stuck to what worked: traditional TV commercials. But their donors were aging, and more digital-savvy nonprofits were catching up by appealing to younger donors.

The goal wasn’t social buzz. It was a reliable revenue stream from a younger generation of animal lovers, who, despite the stereotypes, were often out-giving Boomers when they were reached the right way.

ASPCA rescue
ASPCA campaign still
02 — The insight

Young people give. They just don’t call 1-800 numbers at midnight.

Younger donors text to donate, give blood, and volunteer their time. What they don’t do is call a hotline in the middle of the night because Sarah McLachlan made them cry. So we met them where they already were: online, in social feeds and streaming video.

Broad brand messaging wasn’t the answer. We found the donors the ASPCA was missing through research and targeting, then wrote and designed ads for each segment, and tested everything.

“Help us save animals from becoming statistics”
03 — The strategy

Listen first, then change the ads while they’re live.

The campaign ran from display ads and Facebook posts to viral video and Hulu commercials. Not every spot worked, but each one taught us something. The metrics told us what was and wasn’t working, and we developed new creative every day in response.

As it grew, the program became a full calendar: March Madness brackets to expose dogfighting rings, Valentine’s Day for kitten adoption, Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Month in April to fight hoarding, and real-time posts from puppy-mill rescues alongside law enforcement.

ASPCA display and social ads
Display and social, written for specific donor segments
ASPCA rescue
ASPCA rescue team
04 — Results
→92% new-to-file donor ratio in the first year, and 75% sustained for years after
→Monthly donors up 12% year over year, at a cost per donor 20% under the maximum allowable
→Average donation 18% higher than the aging offline channels
→Digital acquisition became one of the ASPCA’s most profitable sources of monthly donations
→ECHO Gold Award, 2013
Credits

True North Agency

← All work
Next case study
LOST & found: bringing fans back to the island
→